The Truth About Ultra-Processed Food: What the Latest Science Really Shows
ZOE scientists Professor Sarah Berry and Professor Tim Spector explain why ultra-processed food (UPF) has become the centre of a nutrition-science earthquake. Through four key studies they show that processing itself, not just fat, salt and sugar, can drive overeating and poorer health, yet not all processed food is harmful. The practical message: learn to spot the roughly 25% that is genuinely high risk rather than fearing everything in a packet.
Overview
In this ZOE Science & Nutrition conversation, host Jonathan Wolf is joined by Professor Sarah Berry of King's College London and co-founder Professor Tim Spector to unpack the science of ultra-processed foods. They explain the NOVA classification, under which UPF makes up about 55% of calories for adults and 65% for children in the UK and US, and why that label is too broad for everyday shopping.
The pair walk through four studies: Kevin Hall's metabolic-ward trial, where people ate 500 more calories a day on a UPF diet despite matched nutrients; the Elinav sweetener study, which showed artificial sweeteners are not inert and can alter blood sugar and the gut microbiome; the RESTRUCTURE texture study, where softer food led to 369 extra calories a day; and Tera Fazzino's work on hyperpalatable foods and the bliss point.
They discuss emulsifiers, colorants and additive mixtures, and put cancer risk in realistic perspective. Finally they introduce ZOE's new UPF risk score, which grades foods by additives, eating rate and hyperpalatability, and find only about 25% of calories are genuinely high risk. The takeaway is nuanced: do not fear all processed food, but watch yogurts, cereals, ready meals and children's products most closely.
Key quotes
5They were consuming 500 calories more per day when they were on the ultra-processed food diet.
No such thing as a free lunch, and it turns out that we do pick up these chemicals and our bodies do react with them.
The people who were having the hard-textured ultra-processed diet consumed 369 calories less each day compared to those having the soft-textured diet.
That's what the food companies hide behind, and they're very good at disguising what's in their products.
My top tip is: does it look like the original food that it came from? Has the texture been changed so it's very soft or almost pre-digested?
Key ideas
9The NOVA classification and its limits
NOVA sorts foods into four groups by the extent and purpose of processing, with NOVA 4 being ultra-processed. It was built for population research, never captured actual health effects, and is too vague to use reliably as an individual shopper.
How much UPF we really eat
Under NOVA, ultra-processed food accounts for about 55% of calories for adults in the UK and US, and around 65% for adolescents and children. The share is often even higher in the UK than the US.
Kevin Hall's 500-calorie finding
In a metabolic-ward crossover trial, 20 people ate 500 more calories a day on a UPF diet than on a minimally processed one, despite matched fat, sugar, salt and fibre. They gained nearly a kilogram in two weeks and lost nearly one on the whole-food diet.
Eating rate as a hidden driver
On the UPF diet people ate about 50% faster because processing softens texture. ZOE data show faster eaters consume around 120 extra calories a day, so texture and speed, not just additives, help explain overeating.
Sweeteners are not inert
The Elinav study tested four sweeteners in 120 low-exposure people. Saccharin and sucralose blunted the blood-sugar response, and all four shifted the gut microbiome, with effects that vary from person to person.
It may be the mixtures that matter
The French NutriNet-Sante study followed 108,000 people for nearly eight years and found that certain combinations of emulsifiers, dyes, preservatives, gums and acidifiers were linked to higher type 2 diabetes risk, making the cocktail harder to spot.
Texture alone changes intake
In the RESTRUCTURE study, two diets that were both 95% ultra-processed differed only in texture. The harder, chewier diet led people to eat 369 fewer calories a day, about 5,000 fewer over two weeks.
The bliss point and hyperpalatability
Tera Fazzino's group studied foods engineered to override fullness and excite reward through precise fat, salt, sugar and carb ratios. People eating hyperpalatable foods overate by about 300 calories a day, independent of hunger.
ZOE's UPF risk score
ZOE's new score grades food across no, low, moderate and high risk using three features: additives by number and potential risk, energy-intake rate above 72 calories per minute, and a hyperpalatability index. Only about 25% of calories come out as genuinely high risk.
Practical takeaways
6- 1
Don't fear all processed food 14:00
Processing is not automatically bad. Many packaged foods, including some whole-grain breads, cereals and dark chocolate, come out low risk, so blanket avoidance is neither necessary nor realistic.
- 2
Slow down how fast you eat 22:00
Because eating rate drives intake, choosing firmer, chewier foods and simply eating more slowly can meaningfully reduce the calories you take in without dieting.
- 3
Watch yogurts, cereals, ready meals and kids' foods 1:09:00
These are the biggest hidden offenders: naturally healthy-looking products that can be loaded with sweeteners and additives. Treat children's products and sauces with particular care.
- 4
Use the original-food test 1:10:00
If you cannot scan a product, ask whether it still looks and feels like the food it came from, or whether the texture has been made very soft or almost pre-digested.
- 5
Be suspicious of health claims on the front 1:10:30
Front-of-pack claims like low calorie, low fat or no added sugar often signal that a food has been heavily reformulated with sweeteners and additives rather than genuinely improved.
- 6
It's lifelong habits, not the odd treat 1:11:30
An occasional ultra-processed snack or drink is not the problem. The concern is continuous reliance, especially from childhood, so the goal is changing everyday habits over decades.
Topics & chapters
15The ultra-processed food earthquake
Jonathan Wolf introduces the topic and his guests, framing UPF as the centre of a five-year revolution in nutrition science.
What is UPF? The NOVA system
Sarah Berry explains the NOVA classification, NOVA 4, and why it was built for population research rather than individual choices.
How much we eat
The share of calories from UPF: around 55% for adults and 65% for children in the UK and US.
UPF and chronic disease
Tim Spector describes more than 20 population studies linking UPF to outcomes from mental health to cancer, heart disease and diabetes.
Beyond the back-of-pack label
Why nutrients on the label no longer tell the whole story once processing changes a food's structure.
Study 1: Kevin Hall's trial
The metabolic-ward crossover trial showing 500 extra calories a day and a 2 kg weight swing on matched diets.
Eating rate and texture
How softer, processed textures make us eat faster and consume more, a key mechanism behind overeating.
Study 2: The sweetener trial
The Elinav study finding that saccharin and sucralose alter blood sugar and all four sweeteners shift the gut microbiome.
Emulsifiers, colorants and mixtures
A tour of additives, from soy lecithin and beta-carotene to dyes, and the NutriNet-Sante evidence on harmful combinations.
Cancer risk in perspective
Why the realistic increase is in the 20-50% range and largely mediated by overeating and inflammation, not direct additive effects.
Study 3: The RESTRUCTURE study
Two ultra-processed diets differing only in texture, with the chewier one cutting intake by 369 calories a day.
Study 4: The bliss point
Tera Fazzino's work on hyperpalatable foods engineered to override fullness and drive 300 extra calories a day.
Why shoppers can't spot UPF
The difficulty of identifying harmful processing, the price gap, and the burden of playing food detective.
ZOE's UPF risk score
The new score built on additives, eating rate and hyperpalatability, showing only about 25% of calories are high risk.
Practical tips and closing
Rules of thumb, the food groups to watch, and a reassuring message not to fear all processed food.